Intro
The trajectory of Rem, brought to a close by their official split in 2011, arguably represents the most successful attempt at ferrying indie-rock onto the grand stage of the mainstream. Successful commercially, as attested by the sales figures and the six-figure contracts, but above all artistically: Michael Stipe and co., in fact, never sold out, managing to retain the respect of even their longtime fans. From the very debut of "Murmur" they were aware of being the standard-bearers of a new rock nation, that nouvelle vague that would renew the US scene of the '80s-'90s from its very foundations. A squad of independent bands operating against the current, at a safe distance from the spotlights of the music business and the screens of MTV. Unlike their fellow travelers, however, the four kids from Athens, Georgia already possessed every weapon needed to break through the narrow banks of the underground. So, from the glorious era of college radio, which amplified their underground myth, to the "graduation diploma" of "Document", which opened the doors of the majors to them starting with the following "Green", it was simply an evolution in continuity, culminating in the two bestsellers of the early '90s: "Out Of Time", blessed by the hit "Losing My Religion", and, precisely, "Automatic For The People".
Athens soul food
"The only thing to do is not pay attention to it". So declared Peter Buck, faced with the news of those ten million copies sold by the end of '92 which, "lined up end to end, would cover the distance between Athens and Atlanta". Rem could never become America's answer to U2, as Warner dreamed. So, instead of capitalizing on the triumph of "Out Of Time" around the globe, they avoided touring and allowed themselves only sporadic TV appearances. With a touch of hypocrisy, as when at the MTV Music Awards they refused to perform and collected their awards wearing t-shirts with environmentalist and anti-racist slogans, as if determined to underline their otherness at all costs.
In short, the four of them don't seem exactly cut out to become stars. Stipe, more than anyone, appears unable to withstand the pressure. Increasingly introverted, moody and withdrawn into his role as the "misunderstood one", the singer even looks physically transformed: thinning hair, gaunt and painfully thin. Putting two and two together with his sexual orientation and his battles alongside AIDS sufferers, some doom-mongers spread rumors about his supposed HIV-positive status, at times even writing him off entirely. He himself would wait two years before denying it all.
The fact remains that, despite its playful title, inspired by the slogan of an Athens soul food restaurant, "Automatic For The People" is the most pensive and funereal album by Rem. The retreat into ballad form is completed once and for all, in a kind of ideal continuation of the previous record. But this time there are no shiny happy people to clear the mind. Because themes like pain, memory and death are scattered liberally among the lyrics of songs never so dark and introverted. An almost chamber-music austerity is wedded to solemn orchestral arrangements, courtesy of John Paul Jones of Led Zeppelin and Knox Chandler of the Psychedelic Furs. So, if in the past it had almost always been rhythmic, energetic songs that opened their records, this time the register shifts abruptly, into the spectral clarity of the arpeggios of "Drive". A single orchestral guitar line that would become legendary, born as a tribute to Brian May of Queen, with a Les Paul plugged into a huge Marshall, overdubbed six times and played with a coin. Around that device unwinds a spare, moving litany, which Stipe declaims with fatalistic conviction, refracted by echo, before a furious electric guitar and a melodramatic string section take over.
"Drive" is the archetype of this new sound — largely acoustic, subdued and desolate, much like the portrait of youthful disaffection that emerges from its dazed lyrics, in which Stipe urges the kids not to be fooled by politicians. The video is equally telling, showing the singer stage-diving into the hands of a dense, imploring crowd: a vivid representation of the new relationship between the pop icon and its audience.
To the last breath
The anti-commercial choice of a single like "Drive" testified to the Georgians' need to temper the euphoria of success with a deeper reflection on their identity. With an inner world made of memories, losses and yearning. Literally breathtaking, in "Try Not To Breathe", where an elderly person prepares for the end with the sole wish to be remembered. A contrite meditation, in waltz time, amid the superb vocal harmonies of the Stipe-Mills axis, with Buck unveiling one of his most touching acoustic parts, with a solemn organ phrase to seal the ending. One must hold one's breath to overcome the anguish that precedes the final sinking. But the hope that has always accompanied Rem's path ("We are hope despite the times", they sang on "These Days") is renewed even in pain, as in "Everybody Hurts", an anthem urging you not to give up in the face of despair that pushes toward ending it all: the slender triplets of the electric piano support a sturdy melody, sung by Stipe with the searing power of a funeral lament, up to the peak of pathos, amid strings and electric guitar. And with that "No, no, no, you're not alone" echoing Bowie's "Rock 'n' roll Suicide". All the pain in the world condensed into a few, extremely simple lines. With sounds never so saccharine, which run through every convention of melodic pop filtered through REM's aesthetic. It works, despite the pitfalls.
But fully embodying the spirit of the record are also seemingly minor episodes, like "Sweetness Follows", which arrives after the shadowy theme of "New Orleans Instrumental No. 1" to seal another moving requiem in the shape of "an old blues with strange jazz chords stuck in the middle" - as Buck put it - with guitar feedback and the scratches of a distorted cello (courtesy of Chandler) scarring the melody, while the pump organ proceeds solemnly. The theme of death, this time, is read in the eyes of those left behind: the story of a son who must bury his parents becomes the starting point for a reflection on memory and the risk of emotional numbness. An invitation to reclaim the fullness of one's affections.
Closing this cycle of requiems (and the whole tracklist), the sumptuous "Find The River", a country serenade in the style of Fred Neil, where the search for the river serves as yet another existential metaphor. The death of John Seawright, an Athens poet who died of a cerebral hemorrhage while the band was on tour, inspired in Rem an acoustic epitaph of throbbing intensity. Piano-led, with a solemn choir and the breath of the accordion lending depth. A stream of memories, colors, scents. It is the search for the infinite, that eternal longing that drives every individual toward spiritual illumination. An inescapable path, like that of the river toward the ocean.
The river to the ocean goes
A fortune for the undertow
None of this is going my way
There is nothing left to throw
Of ginger, lemon, indigo
Coriander stem and rose of hay
Strength and courage overrides
The privileged and weary eyes
Of river poet search naivete
Pick up here and chase the ride
The river empties to the tide
All of this is coming your way
The river flows toward the ocean
A fortune for the undertow
None of this goes my way
There is nothing left to throw
Of ginger, lemon or indigo
Coriander stems and hay roses
Strength and courage overcome
The tired, privileged eyes
Of the river poet who seeks simplicity
Climb up here and set off on the journey
The river adapts to the tide
Everything goes your way
Monty & Andy got a raw deal
Also coloring the grooves of "Automatic For The People" is a couple of curious cinematic tributes to figures thwarted by fate. Like Montgomery Clift, the American "beautiful and damned" actor of the '50s, already commemorated by the Clash on "London Calling". A figure who – in Stipe's eyes – embodies fame and myth, yes, but also the squandering of success amid alcohol and drugs, as well as being yet another victim of that McCarthyism already stigmatized in "Exhuming McCarthy" ("Document", 1987). In the end "things went wrong for him": "Monty Got A Raw Deal", a perfect title for a sketch that opens with Buck's classic arpeggio and then brushes against exotic shades with the oriental-tinged colors of the refrain and the estranging embroidery of a bouzouki. To the recounting of Monty's ill-fated destiny ("buried in the sand", and "strung up in a tree") Stipe adds a (self-?)admonition not to be blinded by the will-o'-the-wisps of celebrity. The narrative device is a kind of imaginary dialogue with the protagonist, just as in the more famous "Man On The Moon". The man on the moon is Andy Kaufman, the brilliant and hapless comedian of the '60s, specializing in a deranged anti-humor that has more than one point of contact with Stipe's beloved nonsense. The shimmering folk-rock of a few albums earlier is the ideal setting for a ballad that already sounds "classic" on first listen, with its sly swaying moves, dancing between samba and calypso, with Stipe's mischievously Elvis-like delivery and Buck's soaring solo adding an extra touch of epic grandeur. Parodying Elvis was in fact one of the specialties of the misunderstood Kaufman, whose bewildering string of hits and flops is retraced in the lyrics. Not without a touch of bitter disenchantment about the "game of life" and its illusory truths. Thanks to this song Kaufman would be rediscovered, all the way to the eponymous film "Man On The Moon" by Milos Forman, starring Jim Carrey, in which the Rem song would also serve as its soundtrack.
Conclusion
"Automatic For The People" is a collection of songs meticulously crafted from a musical standpoint, already fully formed and vibrant even before acquiring lyrics and choruses. A record that, listening to it today, sounds like a greatest hits, given how many classics it manages to pack into a single tracklist.
The only jarring note, ultimately, is the coarse rock invective of "Ignoreland", in which Stipe rails against the by-then declining Reagan-Bush Republican era. There's too much fervor, too much recklessness in wanting to fire off every round without a single metaphor left in the holster, unlike historic R.E.M. anthems such as "Cuyahoga" or "Begin The Begin". The euphoric yodeling interlude of "The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonite" (from the evergreen "The Lion Sleeps Tonight", made a hit by the Tokens in the '60s) instead serves to ease the tension, with its bizarre pastiche of lives on the margins (the homeless man who "sleeps curled up" and turns away soup kitchens demanding something "more substantial") and childhood memories (the fables of Dr. Seuss, creator of the Grinch). The same goal is pursued by another "minor" track, the eccentric jazz-tinged vignette of perverse love that is "Star Me Kitten".
These are episodes that don't in any case alter the record's overall sense of sober austerity, of which Anton Corbijn's black-and-white shots included in the booklet are the most faithful aesthetic transposition. Even Rem's audience had grown more mature, and understood. Despite selling almost half as many copies as "Out Of Time" in America, "Automatic For The People" would immediately land at No. 2 on the US charts, held off only by the country giant Garth Brooks, and would also take the rest of the world by storm, topping the UK charts and reaching the Top Ten across half of Europe, as well as in Canada and Australia. For Buck and Mills too it remains the band's best album, period. It is certainly the most compact and harmonious. To deny its centrality in Rem's great American novel is less a matter of shortsightedness than of bad faith.
Ghost track
Once upon a time in Athens there were four young guys, a group of friends and boisterous nights out, which ended with swims under the stars in the still waters of Ball Pump lake. "It was a few miles outside town, we'd go there with a few friends to skinny-dip after the clubs closed. There was us, Paul Butchart, DeLoris, Love Tractor, and the girl 'Camera' was about, Carol Levy. Between 1979 and 1981 there were only about 50 to 75 people interested in this music. We'd go to parties, we'd go to clubs, and we'd go to Ball Pump, where there were always some of those same fifty people." It was the Perfect Circle of youth and innocence. Before the specters of drugs and AIDS loomed over an entire generation. In Mills' memory lies the essence of "Nightswimming", a ballad suspended between memory and nostalgia.
Nightswimming deserves a quiet night
The photograph on the dashboard, taken years ago
Turned around backwards so the windshield shows
Every streetlight reveals the picture in reverse
Still, it's so much clearer
I forgot my shirt at the water’s edge
The moon is low tonight
A quiet night is all you need for a night swim
The photo on the dashboard, taken years ago
Turned around backward so it reflects on the windshield
Every streetlight reveals the photo in reverse
But it's just as clear all the same
I forgot my shirt down at the beach
The moon is low tonight
The first sequence is idyllic: the quiet night, lit only by scattered streetlamps, the barely rippling waters of the lake and that old photo on the dashboard. But these are memories now yellowed by the wear of adulthood and all its fears. What does it cost to turn thirty and leave behind those carefree, unburdened days? What is the price of a fame that has forever upended one's habits and way of life? A cyclical, descending piano line, recalling the one in "Perfect Circle" itself, is the backbone of a ballad made even more poignant by the hushed, quivering swell of the strings and Stipe's moved delivery. Written in 1990 under the title "Night Swim", it was meant to appear on "Out Of Time", but found its true home among the dark, melancholy grooves of "Automatic For The People".
We want to remember them like this, the four friends from Athens: happy and excited, swimming in the lake under the moon, still unaware of the bright future awaiting them.
With excerpts from "Rem – Perfect Circle" (Arcana, 2012)
The book, through the analysis of the songs, tells the fairy tale of the four boys from Athens, Georgia, from their beginnings to their breakup. From the wild parties that packed the deconsecrated church on Oconee Street up to the belfry, to the mega-shows of worldwide stardom, Michael Stipe and his bandmates completed the perfect arc. Embodying the anxieties and aspirations of an entire generation. Their songbook is an enigma: as gripping and immediate musically as it is intricate and cryptic in its lyrics. Between dreamlike sketches and heartfelt political exhortations, childhood memories and neurotic, introspective portraits. But in R.E.M.'s trajectory one can also read the transformations of thirty years of American society, passing through the anguish of the Cold War and imperialism, the contradictions of the Reagan era, the optimism of the Clinton years and the season of terror and conflict after 9/11. An epic condensed into an astonishing sequence of killer choruses.
Add OndaRock to your favorite sources on Google Discover. Don't miss our reviews, milestones and latest news straight in your feed.
31/08/2014
This article is an English translation of the original Italian text by Claudio Fabretti, published on OndaRock.it. It was translated with the help of artificial intelligence, under the editorial responsibility of OndaRock's editor-in-chief, Claudio Fabretti.