Afterhours - Seeds of Italian alt-rock

interview by Giovanni Dozzini

He's on tour with Afterhours, as always. In early May he'll play a handful of dates with Cesare Basile, lending him piano and a bit of vocals, alongside longtime comrades Rodrigo D'Erasmo and Enrico Gabrielli. A few days ago he was called on to close out the seventh edition of the Perugia International Journalism Festival, where he discussed the prospects of Italian music with Luca Valtorta of Xl, Davide Toffolo, Roberta Sammarelli of Verdena, Giovanni Gulino of Marta sui Tubi, and Tommaso Colliva of Calibro 35. Manuel Agnelli just can't stop to catch his breath. He's someone who, whether singing or talking, never says anything trivial. A man with a clear idea of his place in the world, and a great drive to keep working. As always. On Sunday, April 28th, he found himself caught up in this whirlwind of journalists of every stripe, all busy sizing each other up and checking themselves in the mirror, and for him it must have been a curious experience.

The press, right.

I used to read the music press religiously, especially as a kid. And I think some magazines were fundamental to the development of the Italian music scene, and to its growth too. I mean for musicians, of course, but also for the audience. I think less highly of the mainstream press, which has always paid little attention to music. Lately, to tell the truth, things are changing - the big newspapers are giving music a lot of space. Too bad it's happening right in the middle of this huge crisis for the press. And maybe that's not a coincidence.

And the internet? Every day a new music blog is born, run by people who feel entitled to pass themselves off as journalists, and who might want to interview, review, dispute.

Certainly when there was only print, the selection process was tougher. Emerging was harder work, and those who made it had more skill and more competence. On the internet there's total freedom and everyone uses it as they see fit. You often end up dealing with people who aren't well prepared, that's true, but what bothers me most is the superficiality. On paper, words stay put, and before writing something you might think twice about it. On the web there are no filters, a lot of people write without thinking. And that goes for music journalism too: sometimes certain comments seem to me mostly the product of personal frustration.

A few years ago, around the time of "Il Paese è reale", in an interview for Corriere dell'Umbria you told me you felt like a mature man who wanted to have a role in society. When you look at how society has been reduced, at its inability to change and mend its ways, don't you ever feel like not giving a damn about it? Like saying "from now on I'm just thinking about myself, goodnight"?

But I already do think about myself. The role I want to have isn't forced - it's just who I am. I believe in what I do regardless of the results. With Tora Tora, for instance, I didn't think I could change the state of Italian music in a few months, or even a few years. These are always long processes, but things like that always contribute to change. The point is it takes time, and people have little patience. Also because in Italy we're very provincial, full of divisions and small-town rivalries, even in music. Going back to your question: no, I'm not tired. I get real satisfaction out of organizing these things, and I'm fine with it even if the results are small, or nonexistent.

A couple of years ago Cristina Donà told me that, as far as she knew, you were thinking about putting Tora Tora back together. Is that true?

It's true, yes, I am thinking about it. I'm convinced this is the right moment to bring back something with those characteristics, that spirit. I don't know when, but it will happen. The thing is, as always, taking the initiative earns you plenty of enemies who accuse you of the presumption of handing yourself the license of innovator or revolutionary. In reality, everyone does what they can, and so do I.

You were invited to the Festival del Giornalismo to talk about the future of music, but the present comes first. In Italy today, you don't see that many genuinely new ideas. With the web, anyone can produce a record shut away in their bedroom, but where's the original stuff?

It's a complicated subject, and I'll just give you my opinion. The fact that everyone can make records shouldn't be a problem in itself, but it's true that it does create one. There's no filter, there's less self-censorship, it's hard to grow and to accept and use criticism. Still, there are interesting things happening today, which unfortunately get surrounded, almost hidden, by a ton of mediocre stuff. Compared to our era, there's an enormous fear of engaging with the outside world. In the Nineties everyone tried to break out of their own little garden, to open up to the outside, achieving remarkable communicative power. Now there's fear, and the internet certainly bears a lot of the responsibility. There's a sense that you can live protected without talking to the world, and so you end up self-ghettoizing. That way you don't grow. You need to get your hands dirty, influence each other, or you won't get anywhere.

Afterhours have always had a scope and points of reference strongly tied to international music. What records are you listening to right now, which bands do you think have got something extra?

I listen to very little international music. A lot of the new bands everyone's hailing as a miracle, I don't like at all. Take Sigur Rós. I've seen them live three times: after three songs you can't take it anymore. Listening to them on record is better, if anything, but a couple of albums are more than enough - they're an interesting band, but they used up that idea of theirs a long time ago. It's all the product of American and British marketing, which sells us just about anything. We're grandiose suckers. Right now, for instance, I'm listening back to a lot of stuff from the past. Naturally I do it with different ears, and there are things I appreciate more or less, and others I completely reassess. Italy is better, anyway. I could name quite a few. I really like Ovo, for example, or Fuzz Orchestra. But also people from my own generation, like Cesare Basile. His latest record is beautiful. There really are many Italian projects capable of expressing the present, of telling the story of their own country. I'll certainly do my part to help make them known, whether by organizing festivals or in some other way.

***

Interview by Magda Di Genova

“Hello?”

“Are you coming for dinner tonight?”

"...Huh? Who is it? ...Mum? ...Tonight? No, I have to interview Manuel Agnelli: I managed to get ten minutes at some unspecified hour. I don't know when I'll be free. Mum, it's late, I have to go".

Agnelli??!! I mean, you two get sloshed together every week and for ten minutes you have to request an audience?

"It's not quite like that: you have to request the interview and find the time and the opportunity. Besides, it's not like Manuel and I have ever been drinking buddies: we run into each other in the evening at gigs, say hello and exchange a couple of pleasantries at most. We're not blood brothers! Mum, it's late, I have to go".

"Ask him when he's getting his hair cut, because he looks much better with short hair".

"Yes, look, in a ten-minute interview that question is a must. Wait, let me write it down, otherwise I'll forget it".

"Good girl. Call me when you're free, so you can tell me if you're coming for dinner".

And she hangs up without saying goodbye. Then again, I was in a hurry...

When you go to the supermarket to do your shopping and buy hair conditioner, does the checkout girl stare at you?

Eehh... No, not anymore. (smiles)

(I open the notebook with the questions and catch Agnelli peeking)

Don't peek!

No, no, who's peeking! Besides, I can't make out a thing from your handwriting!

Two double DVDs coming out. Not a simple collection of promotional videoclips, but a huge assortment of concert clips, TV appearances, prank calls, vintage photographs, interviews and a documentary on the US tour. Were you bored?

No, I'd say definitely not, quite the opposite! It was very much by chance that we made this DVD. Actually, the original idea was a boring one: let's make a DVD about the Ballate per piccole iene tour, which was a triumphant tour, which had gone really well, where we'd played some galactic shows, but in my opinion a bit stiff: watching the footage back we said: "But... though... I remembered it being better... we're playing a bit stiffly...", and digging through the material we had, every now and then we'd stumble on a clip from '97 that was actually a killer. At a certain point we said to ourselves: "Why do we have to put together a piece following a rigid concept? Let's make something with the best of what we've got, following this kind of approach, let's put in the best stuff". That's how we started, and we widened the scope with a ton of recordings, we went and tracked down and interviewed the people who had worked with us over these twenty years, and other ideas came out of that.

It really was a work in progress that went on for several months.

We had a blast doing it, honestly. Like when you make a scrapbook back in middle school: cutting out photographs…

How long did it take you to "put it all together"?

Many months. The actual technical work took a couple of months in the end, but between choosing the tracks, selecting them, looking them over, setting a direction… more than a year.

From what I understand, "Ballads For Little Hyenas" is doing really well abroad. You've just come back from an endless run of sold-out shows and now you're heading off to the US again. Did you expect that?

It's going well. "Really well" is a relative concept: we're not selling hundreds of thousands of copies. We've got small but very fertile pockets scattered around Europe and the United States. These are things we want to nurture, definitely not out of some career ambition, as a lot of people have said… things where, at forty, you can't exactly think you're going to redo fifteen years of paying your dues in Arkansas! In reality, this dimension is very important to us: it's a different dimension from the one we live in Italy, and so we hold onto it tightly. Absolutely.

Isn't that traumatic?

No, it's traumatic if you're not ready to experience certain things because you don't want to experience them, because you want to settle for what you have, or because you want to enjoy yourself without seeing what you've achieved. For us, the enjoyment always comes from putting ourselves on the line, that's far more stimulating: going outside Italy, the harder it is, the more it is, for us, a pleasure. In the United States, honestly, we went in with our armor and shields up, and instead we ended up having the best tour of our lives. We were the ones with the preconceptions about them, not the other way around.

So… when you go abroad, does the audience come to see you, or do they go to the venue just because they know there's a show on?

The first time we did the United States, the audience definitely came for the headliners and then discovered us. But this is what happens in America: there's an enormous word-of-mouth effect, especially thanks to the internet, so if the first three or four shows go well, the people who saw us start talking up the opening act, and that's exactly what happened to us. Online, word spread that said: "Get there early because the opening band kicks ass." People started showing up earlier and earlier, and we'd be playing to venues already packed by 8:30 in the evening. That happens there, they're very curious.

In the rest of Europe we have niche followings in Spain, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands; very small but very fierce pockets of fans. In England we're just starting to build that now.

Just curious, how many records do you sell after a show abroad?

In America we sold 700 copies over 24 dates. If you think about it, that's a good number.

Any copies in Italian?

Yes, yes! They're very intrigued by the Italian language. 50% of the setlist abroad is always in Italian.

Doesn't anyone get impatient?

No! If the whole setlist were in Italian that would probably happen. Actually, the fact that it's 50/50 builds a bridge towards them.

You started out in English and after twenty years you've gone back to English.

For the same reasons: we started in English because there was no scene in Italy, so we looked abroad and our models were English. We went back to English when we decided to get out of Italy, out of this "gilded cage". We're aware that English is a very communicative language, and also a lot of fun to sing: it lets me redo the same songs even after three or four years with the same freshness, because they're in another language, so, for me, they're still a new song anyway.

Tell me about when you were received by the then President of the Republic, Carlo Azeglio Ciampi.

It was wild, because we had a nomination for the David di Donatello for "best original song in a soundtrack" (“Gioia e Rivoluzione” for Guido Chiesa's film “Lavorare con Lentezza”), which, considering it was thought to be a cover of Area, is kind of funny. But it was an original version: it was played by us, reworked. In fact we didn't win... But we went to the Quirinale, which is wonderful. It has some incredible rooms inside, and we saw a few personalities... uh... I don't know... what's her name, the one with the huge boobs... the diva, come on... the one married to the guy from Florence...

Marini?

Yes, from Valeria Marini to Carlo Azeglio Ciampi. He's actually really likeable, a person with a very natural charm.

We didn't get the chance to actually interact with all these people: we were sitting next to them, but, well, you get a sense of what the atmosphere is like.

It was a very institutional affair and, for us, a lot of fun. We had a driver with a limousine...

So that's where my tax money goes! To drive Afterhours around in a limousine!

Exactly! Not bad, keep it up! (we laugh)

After you raised your left fist during the May Day concert a couple of years ago, the following editions of the event were broadcast on tape delay. How do you deal with the extraordinary media power you wield?

That's not why they put it on tape delay! (laughs) At May Day! If I'd done it who knows where else!

I don't actually have much media power: there are some very simple little rules for not getting bored. Actually, every now and then I do have something to say, and over time I've learned the most enjoyable way to communicate it... enjoyable for me... and I think that's as far as it goes: there's nothing else to it, nothing deeper than that.

I'm very lucky: people ask me what I think, and that's an incredible stroke of luck. I want to hold onto it, and above all I want to do it without becoming pompous, or gloomy, or worse, tacky, so I try to do it in the lightest and most enjoyable way possible.

Sometimes this kind of irony isn't understood, but that's part of the rules of the game. The price you have to pay is minimal compared to the satisfactions.

There's always someone who fires back at you, and you have to factor that in.

More than firing back, there's a segment of people who, I think, hate us for some reason. Some don't know us at all, others have a very blurry image of who we are and adapt it to fit their hatred – let's put it this way: we're fodder for their hatred – others know us very well and are envious, and still others probably know us well and have a very analytical, often excessive, critical spirit, but, honestly, a very interesting one. And that critical spirit really helps us question ourselves and never rest on what we've already done, while at the same time it stirs up the kind of anger that makes us react to certain situations. So thanks to everyone who hates us.

"How did the interview go?"

"Pretty well... I'm missing a knife, can you pass me one?"

"Did you ask him when he's going to cut his hair?"

"No, mom, I didn't ask Manuel Agnelli when he's cutting his hair"

"But then he'll never cut it!"

"But I did ask him about conditioner"

"Conditioner?"

"Yes, hair conditioner"

"I don't understand. What does that have to do with anything?"

"Remind me to lend you a book"

(Milan, February 16, 2007)

OndaRock Logo

Ride the wave of great music

Add OndaRock to your favorite sources on Google Discover. Don't miss our reviews, milestones and latest news straight in your feed.

This article is an English translation of the original Italian text by Giovanni Dozzini, published on OndaRock.it. It was translated with the help of artificial intelligence, under the editorial responsibility of OndaRock's editor-in-chief, Claudio Fabretti.

Read the original in Italian · About the English edition

Afterhours on OndaRock

Discography

AFTERHOURS
All The Good Children Go To Hell (mini-lp, Toast, 1988) 5
During Christine's Sleep (Vox Pop, 1990) 5
Cocaine Head (mini-LP, Vox Pop, 1992) 5
Pop Kills Your Soul (Vox Pop, 1993) 5
Germi (Vox Pop, 1995) 7
Are You Afraid of the Dark? (Mescal, 1997) 8
Non è per sempre (Mescal, 1999) 7
Siam tre piccoli porcellin (live, Mescal, 2001) 6
Quello che non c'è (Mescal, 2002) 7.5
Ballate per piccole iene (Mescal, 2005) 8
Ballads For Little Hyenas (Mescal/One Little Indian, 2006) 6
Non usate precauzioni, lasciatevi infettare (DVD, Virgin, 2007)
Cuori e demoni (double CD, anthology, EMI, 2008) 6
Le sessioni ricreative (EP, Universal, 2008) 5
The Milanese kill off Saturday night (Universal, 2008) 6
Afterhours presents: Il paese è reale (compilation, Casasonica, 2009) 5
Meet Some Freaks On Route 66 (bundled with XL Repubblica, 2012) 5.5
Padania (Artist First, 2012) 7
Are You Afraid of the Dark? Special Edition (Universal, 2014) 8
Folfiri o Folfox (Universal, 2016) 7.5
Foto di pura gioia (compilation, Universal, 2017)
Noi siamo Afterhours (live, 2019)
MANUEL AGNELLI
Ama il prossimo tuo come te stesso (Universal, 2022) 7
Milestone
Recommended by OR